
Species comparison
Camponotus barbaricus vs Camponotus nicobarensis
Side by side: difficulty, size, growth, climate, hibernation and nuptial flights, from the data and sources of each species sheet.


Camponotus nicobarensis
Nicobar carpenter ant
Head to head
| Camponotus barbaricus | Fact | Camponotus nicobarensis |
|---|---|---|
| Keeping | ||
| Difficulty | ||
4/7 Beginner | Difficulty | 4/7 Beginner |
| Escape risk | ||
LowerMedium | Escape risk | High |
| Diet | ||
SugarInsects | Diet | SugarInsects |
| Best nests | ||
Ytong nest · Acrylic nest · Naturalistic setup | Best nests | Ytong nest · Acrylic nest · Wooden nest |
| Colony | ||
| Growth | ||
Fast | Growth | FasterVery fast |
| Colony size | ||
Reaches 10,000 workers | Colony size | Reaches 10,000 workers |
| Workers | ||
6–12 mm majors up to 16 mm | Workers | 5–8 mm majors up to 12 mm |
| Queen | ||
16–18 mm | Queen | 14–16 mm |
| Colony founding | ||
Fully claustral One queen | Colony founding | Fully claustral One queen |
| Defense | ||
Bites · Sprays formic acid | Defense | Bites · Sprays formic acid |
| Climate | ||
| Nest temperature | ||
25–30 °C | Nest temperature | 22–28 °C |
| Nest humidity | ||
40–60 % | Nest humidity | 50–70 % |
| Hibernation | ||
12–18 °C Nov – Feb | Hibernation | Not needed |
| Nuptial flights | ||
Jun – Aug Hot days · Calm weather | Nuptial flights | Mar – Jun |
| Native range | ||
Europe, North Africa | Native range | Asia |
Size to scale
Camponotus barbaricus
Workers ·6–12 mmMajors ·≤ 16 mmQueen ·16–18 mmCamponotus nicobarensis
Workers ·5–8 mmMajors ·≤ 12 mmQueen ·14–16 mm
Their year side by side
Camponotus barbaricus : Hibernation: Nov – Feb, Nuptial flights: Jun – Aug
Camponotus nicobarensis : Nuptial flights: Mar – Jun
Months in the native range of the species. The weather decides the exact days, and colonies kept indoors can follow a different rhythm.
How to tell them apart
Camponotus barbaricus
Glossy black workers in many sizes, with a black head and gaster and a thorax that runs from black to dark red or orange between individuals and colonies, so shipments from different places can look quite different. Compared with Camponotus cruentatus the body is shinier and the gaster has no orange band, and since the name also covers regional forms such as the subspecies xanthomelas, the exact identity of shop colonies is rarely certain.
- Tip Heat only one side of the nest. One colony stayed tiny for years at room temperature and took off after a heat mat was added, and since eggs, young larvae and pupae choose different spots, a warm end with a cooler corner works best.
- Watch out Do not rely on smooth glass or a thin coating, because the workers climb vertical glass, walk upside down and in one journal walked straight over a PTFE spray. Keep lids tight with no gaps, and feed in an outworld rather than inside the test tube, where some workers rush out and get lost when it is opened.
Camponotus nicobarensis
Brown to reddish-brown workers of many sizes, from small minors to much larger majors, with long, dense, erect hairs all over the body. The gaster is plain brownish, not banded in black and yellow like the similar Camponotus habereri, and colors vary with the origin of the stock, which is why some shops list it as 'cf. nicobarensis'.
- Watch out Treat them as climbers: keepers report workers walking up glass and even jumping. Use a tight lid with a barrier such as paraffin oil or Fluon, and seal every gap, because some ants died squeezing between a Ytong nest and the glass.
- Tip Offer sugar as syrup or sugar water on a piece of cotton or in a feeder, not as open drops: the workers run through the drops, stick and drown, and one keeper lost several that way. Taste varies between colonies, and some ignored plain sugar water but loved invert syrup, so try a second sweet food if one is refused.
More comparisons
Not sure which ant to keep?
Take the 1-minute species finder quiz and get matched with the perfect species for your experience, your space and what you'd love to watch.


