Species comparison

Camponotus nicobarensis vs Camponotus pennsylvanicus

Side by side: difficulty, size, growth, climate, hibernation and nuptial flights, from the data and sources of each species sheet.

Head to head

Camponotus nicobarensis and Camponotus pennsylvanicus compared fact by fact
Camponotus nicobarensisCamponotus pennsylvanicus
Keeping
Difficulty
4/7

Beginner

4/7

Beginner

Escape risk
High
LowerMedium
Diet
SugarInsects
SugarInsects
Best nests
Ytong nest · Acrylic nest · Wooden nest
Ytong nest · Wooden nest · Naturalistic setup
Colony
Growth
FasterVery fast
Moderate
Colony size
Reaches 10,000 workers
Reaches 15,000 workers
Workers
5–8 mm

majors up to 12 mm

6–10 mm

majors up to 13 mm

Queen
14–16 mm
15–18 mm
Colony founding
Fully claustral

One queen

Fully claustral

One queen

Defense
Bites · Sprays formic acid
Bites · Sprays formic acid
Climate
Nest temperature
22–28 °C
22–27 °C
Nest humidity
50–70 %
50–70 %
Hibernation
Not needed
5–10 °C

Oct – Feb

Nuptial flights
Mar – Jun
Apr – Jul

Hot days · Calm weather

Native range
Asia
North America

Size to scale

  • Camponotus nicobarensis

    Workers5–8 mm
    Majors≤ 12 mm
    Queen14–16 mm
  • Camponotus pennsylvanicus

    Workers6–10 mm
    Majors≤ 13 mm
    Queen15–18 mm
10 mm: both species are drawn at the same scale

Their year side by side

  • Camponotus nicobarensis : Nuptial flights: Mar – Jun

  • Camponotus pennsylvanicus : Hibernation: Oct – Feb, Nuptial flights: Apr – Jul

Months in the native range of the species. The weather decides the exact days, and colonies kept indoors can follow a different rhythm.

How to tell them apart

Camponotus nicobarensis

Brown to reddish-brown workers of many sizes, from small minors to much larger majors, with long, dense, erect hairs all over the body. The gaster is plain brownish, not banded in black and yellow like the similar Camponotus habereri, and colors vary with the origin of the stock, which is why some shops list it as 'cf. nicobarensis'.

  • Watch out Treat them as climbers: keepers report workers walking up glass and even jumping. Use a tight lid with a barrier such as paraffin oil or Fluon, and seal every gap, because some ants died squeezing between a Ytong nest and the glass.
  • Tip Offer sugar as syrup or sugar water on a piece of cotton or in a feeder, not as open drops: the workers run through the drops, stick and drown, and one keeper lost several that way. Taste varies between colonies, and some ignored plain sugar water but loved invert syrup, so try a second sweet food if one is refused.

Camponotus pennsylvanicus

Large, all-black workers of many sizes, with pale yellowish to golden hairs lying flat on the gaster, long and dense on the bigger workers. Camponotus herculeanus and western C. modoc have short gaster hairs, and C. herculeanus usually has a dark reddish thorax or legs, while C. chromaiodes often shows red on the thorax, legs or gaster base and C. novaeboracensis has a red thorax and legs.

  • Tip Keep the founding queen in a dark, quiet spot and check on her rarely. Her first clutch is small and takes at least about 60 days to become workers. One keeper who checked a queen daily and moved her between three setups lost the early brood and waited about 87 days for the first worker. Ending the first year with 5 to 30 workers is normal.
  • Watch out Check cotton plugs and water barriers all year, including during the winter rest. The workers chew cotton, soft plastic and plaster, and one keeper found a hibernating colony drowned after it had chewed through the cotton in its test tube. Fluon or talc keeps them in on smooth walls, but oil or petroleum jelly on a vertical wall does not.

More comparisons

Compare
with

Not sure which ant to keep?

Take the 1-minute species finder quiz and get matched with the perfect species for your experience, your space and what you'd love to watch.